The Student Room Group

Why is the political left now censorious and authoritarian??

Why?? The young generation on the left seem to feel very comfortable with the silencing of unacceptable opinions. Quite disturbing how they don't seem to recall or appreciate that in the previous era, speech was so much freer and this was treasured.

Scroll to see replies

Reply 1
Almost like China under Chairman Mao, Germany under Hitler and most Russian eras. Only like the sound of their own voice!
I'm a socialist economically left leaning but not pc on cultural issues. I find little political common ground with the new generation.
Reply 3
Original post by SaucissonSecCy
Better make sure that post isn't cancelled by the mods.

Wouldn't be the first and would only cement what I have said. There is very much a culture in the younger left in trying to shout down anyone who won't conform to their ideals.
Original post by SaucissonSecCy
Why?? The young generation on the left seem to feel very comfortable with the silencing of unacceptable opinions. Quite disturbing how they don't seem to recall or appreciate that in the previous era, speech was so much freer and this was treasured.

Less tolerant possibly, more awareness on how things can upset people, maybe gets offended easier, afraid to call a spade a spade or being told not do that in fear of being hounded/silenced or being told “you’re making us look bad” (I’ve experienced this last point first hand) etc . That’s just my theory, not facts.

I don’t know if this this a left-wing young generation thing though as opposed to maybe a culture thing or people being more aware. I feel like in France for example, people seem to be a lot more blunt, they’ll call a spade a spade, no beating around the bush, facts over feelings. At least that’s what I seem to see but I could easily be wrong.

How I view it:
The left likes to say that they are tolerant and progressive but I only see the opposite.

The right likes to say that they aren’t obsessed with things like identity politics and they have the common sense (over the left) but I only see the opposite.

What am I?
Mostly left-wing and progressive with some conservative and right-wing beliefs.
You're just mad because your white replacement conspiracy thread got rightfully moderated 🤐
Original post by Talkative Toad
Less tolerant possibly, more awareness on how things can upset people, maybe gets offended easier, afraid to call a spade a spade or being told not do that in fear of being hounded/silenced or being told “you’re making us look bad” (I’ve experienced this last point first hand) etc . That’s just my theory, not facts.
I don’t know if this this a left-wing young generation thing though as opposed to maybe a culture thing or people being more aware. I feel like in France for example, people seem to be a lot more blunt, they’ll call a spade a spade, no beating around the bush, facts over feelings. At least that’s what I seem to see but I could easily be wrong.
How I view it:
The left likes to say that they are tolerant and progressive but I only see the opposite.
The right likes to say that they aren’t obsessed with things like identity politics and they have the common sense (over the left) but I only see the opposite.
What am I?
Mostly left-wing and progressive with some conservative and right-wing beliefs.

I often feel 'tolerant' has become a but twisted, 'tolerance' has got us years and years of Tory decline, 'tolerance' has left us enabling the Trumps of the world.

Sometimes I think you need to... NOT tolerate things, like I'm not about to tolerate TSR members posting that if your skin isn't white you can't be British like a certain OP did last night.
Original post by StriderHort
You're just mad because your white replacement conspiracy thread got rightfully moderated 🤐

I didn't mention any conspiracy. Only pointed to verifiable demographic facts about London's trajectory.
Original post by StriderHort
I often feel 'tolerant' has become a but twisted, 'tolerance' has got us years and years of Tory decline, 'tolerance' has left us enabling the Trumps of the world.
Sometimes I think you need to... NOT tolerate things, like I'm not about to tolerate TSR members posting that if your skin isn't white you can't be British like a certain OP did last night.

Once again putting words in my mouth. Attributing to me something I didn't say.
(edited 4 weeks ago)
If your idea of censorious and authoritarian is being told to zip it by some woke hippy with green hair, you really should try the conservative utopia of Russia.
Original post by SaucissonSecCy
Once again putting words in my mouth. Attributing to me something I didn't say.

You seemed to make it quite clear you thought people who weren't white weren't British.

Your words were either astonishingly poorly chosen or plain racist. Your thread had already been locked by the time I read it so It's hardly just myself that objected.
Original post by StriderHort
You seemed to make it quite clear you thought people who weren't white weren't British.
Your words were either astonishingly poorly chosen or plain racist. Your thread had already been locked by the time I read it so It's hardly just myself that objected.

I didn't say that, again. You interpreted it that way. Are we not allowed to discuss radical demographic change as at least an interesting and profound change?
Original post by SaucissonSecCy
I didn't say that, again. You interpreted it that way. Are we not allowed to discuss radical demographic change as at least an interesting and profound change?


Do you think the onus is on me for misinterpreting or you for explaining yourself in a way likely to cause offence? Again, I clearly wasn't the only one that took issue with it, you equated skin colour to nationality.

You said that London is starting to feel like a 'different country' and postulated it leaving the UK, I queried whether you felt this was a result of multiculturalism (which I feel is a valid position) but you went one further and claimed it was skin colour, so the message seems to be that no matter your actual history in the UK you will always be seen as 'foreign' and not considered a UK national like any other if your skin isn't white? anything else is a perpetual outsider and and is presumed not to share our values? Do you not see how that could offend or marginalise people? You'd be on reasonable arguments with language and cultural differences, but bringing colour into it was needlessly divisive.
Original post by SaucissonSecCy
Why?? The young generation on the left seem to feel very comfortable with the silencing of unacceptable opinions. Quite disturbing how they don't seem to recall or appreciate that in the previous era, speech was so much freer and this was treasured.

When was this "previous era"? Who are these left wing people "silencing unacceptable opinions"?

Give some examples instead of talking about nebulous concepts.
Nah. Yawn. Can't be bothered with the supercilious, sanctimonious and entitled.
Original post by SaucissonSecCy
Why?? The young generation on the left seem to feel very comfortable with the silencing of unacceptable opinions. Quite disturbing how they don't seem to recall or appreciate that in the previous era, speech was so much freer and this was treasured.

You must be a Nazi Bigot, to protect democacy we must censor and fight those that dont have the right views #votelabour2024
Admin take this thread down its hate speach and hurting my communities feelings
Original post by SaucissonSecCy
Nah. Yawn. Can't be bothered with the supercilious, sanctimonious and entitled.


You started this thread. It transpired in subsequent posts that you started it in bad faith because you felt personally slighted over some mod decision on TSR rather than making a general argument. You had your position challenged and now you are running away with your tail between your legs.

It all makes for an entertaining read.
Original post by Gazpacho.
You started this thread. It transpired in subsequent posts that you started it in bad faith because you felt personally slighted over some mod decision on TSR rather than making a general argument. You had your position challenged and now you are running away with your tail between your legs.
It all makes for an entertaining read.

They should ban him, those that challenge (in this case attacking and having the wrong language) is why we have cancel culture, to cancel these bigots that only spout hate and have no idea what they are talking about. Definitly a Con/reform voter. #jermycorbin #votelab
Original post by Gazpacho.
You started this thread. It transpired in subsequent posts that you started it in bad faith because you felt personally slighted over some mod decision on TSR rather than making a general argument. You had your position challenged and now you are running away with your tail between your legs.
It all makes for an entertaining read.
Sure the topic came to mind because someone was censorious, so what? If it isn't generally true that society has massively changed in this regard you must be very young or living under a rock. Of course it's a general argument. And like I say, tone down the supercilious entitlement please, just proving my point.

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending